Two Can Keep a Secret was as good as McManus’s first book, One of Us is Lying! Once again she told the story through the perspectives of the main characters, Ellery and Malcolm, and in a suspenseful way that kept me guessing right until the end! Only this time, I didn’t figure out who the killer was early on in the book.

I loved the mystery of trying to connect the missing homecoming queens with Ellery and Ezra’s aunt who went missing years ago. Just as well, I loved the setting (I absolutely LOVE Vermont!) and I really think that Ezra and Mia need their own book now. They were just two amazing, outspoken characters that didn’t get enough page-time.

Overall, this is another great YA Mystery/Thriller for anyone who loves the genre!

Rating: 5/5 stars